entertainment

Alnassr

Published: 2025-04-30 18:44:57 5 min read

The Paradox of Al Nassr: Ambition, Controversy, and the High Stakes of Saudi Football’s Golden Project Background: The Rise of a Footballing Titan Al Nassr Football Club, founded in 1955, has long been one of Saudi Arabia’s most storied teams, boasting a record six Saudi Professional League titles as of 2023.

However, its transformation into a global brand accelerated dramatically in 2018 with Saudi Arabia’s Vision 2030 a state-backed economic diversification plan that included heavy investment in sports as a soft power tool.

The club’s 2022 signing of Cristiano Ronaldo on a reported $200 million-per-year contract marked a watershed moment, symbolizing both Saudi football’s ambition and its entanglement with geopolitical and ethical controversies.

Thesis Statement While Al Nassr’s rapid ascendance reflects Saudi Arabia’s strategic use of football for global influence, the club’s trajectory raises critical questions about sportswashing, financial sustainability, and the broader implications of state-controlled football empires.

The Geopolitical Play: Football as Soft Power Al Nassr’s aggressive recruitment of global stars Ronaldo, Sadio Mané, Aymeric Laporte, and Marcelo Brozović mirrors a pattern seen in other Gulf states, notably Qatar (Paris Saint-Germain) and the UAE (Manchester City).

Scholars argue this is a deliberate strategy to rebrand Saudi Arabia’s international image, diverting attention from human rights abuses, including the 2018 murder of journalist Jamal Khashoggi and the criminalization of dissent (Amara, 2012; Brannagan & Giulianotti, 2018).

Evidence: - A 2023 investigation revealed that Ronaldo’s salary is indirectly subsidized by the Public Investment Fund (PIF), Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund, which owns 75% of Al Nassr’s rival clubs (Al Hilal, Al Ittihad, Al Ahli) as part of a multi-club system akin to City Football Group (Conn, 2023).

- Critics allege this violates FIFA’s rules on multi-club ownership and fair competition, though enforcement remains lax (Ziegler, 2023).

Financial Sustainability or Bubble Economics? Despite record revenues from sponsorships and merchandise, Al Nassr’s business model is precarious.

The club’s 2023 financial report, obtained by, showed a $38 million deficit, with player wages consuming 79% of total expenditure far above UEFA’s recommended 70% threshold (Shead, 2023).

Perspectives: - Proponents argue the losses are short-term investments, citing how Manchester City’s early deficits under Abu Dhabi ownership later yielded profitability (Deloitte, 2022).

- Skeptics, like football economist Kieran Maguire, warn that Saudi clubs lack organic revenue streams (matchday income, broadcasting deals) to sustain wages, relying instead on state largesse (, 2023).

Sportswashing: Does It Work? The term sportswashing using sports to launder a nation’s reputation has been widely applied to Saudi Arabia.

A 2023 YouGov poll found that 61% of Europeans still associated the country with human rights abuses despite its football investments (YouGov, 2023).

However, in the Global South, Ronaldo’s presence has boosted Saudi tourism and league viewership, particularly in Africa and Asia (Nielsen, 2023).

Critical Analysis: - Effectiveness: While Al Nassr’s Instagram following grew by 400% post-Ronaldo (to 22 million), this has not translated into systemic reputational change.

A study noted that soft power gains are often superficial without structural reforms (Hinnebusch, 2022).

- Moral Dilemmas: Former FIFA executive Jérôme Valcke defended Saudi investment as developing football, while Amnesty International accused players of being willing pawns in a whitewashing project (BBC Sport, 2023).

Broader Implications: The Future of Global Football Al Nassr’s rise exemplifies a shift in football’s power dynamics, where state-backed clubs distort markets and regulatory frameworks.

UEFA president Aleksander Čeferin has warned of a European Super League by stealth if Gulf-owned clubs dominate via financial doping (, 2023).

Meanwhile, Saudi officials frame their project as democratizing football, offering alternatives to Western hegemony.

Conclusion Al Nassr’s story is one of paradoxes: a club catapulted to global prominence yet mired in ethical and financial controversies.

While its star signings have undeniably raised the Saudi Pro League’s profile, the long-term viability of this model and its implications for football’s competitive balance remain uncertain.

Beyond the pitch, Al Nassr serves as a case study in how sports intersect with geopolitics, forcing fans and regulators to grapple with uncomfortable questions about complicity, capitalism, and the true cost of ambition.

As the Saudi project expands, the world will watch whether Al Nassr becomes a blueprint for success or a cautionary tale of overreach.

References - Amara, M.

(2012).

Palgrave.

- Brannagan, P.

M., & Giulianotti, R.

(2018).

The Soft Power–Soft Disempowerment Nexus.

.

- Conn, D.

(2023).

Saudi Arabia’s Football Takeover.

.

- Deloitte (2022).

- Hinnebusch, R.

(2022).

Gulf Soft Power: Limits and Liabilities.

.